Weekly Analysis by Peter Wilson
Wellington, June 18, 2021
The government’s feebate Scheme divides Parliament as National vows to reverse it, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announces that there will be a formal apology for the dawn raids of the 1970s and the vaccine rollout plan for the general population is revealed.
The government began the week by announcing a “feebate” Scheme designed to increase the uptake of electric vehicles, and National’s leader Judith Collins immediately vowed to reverse the policy if her Party wins the next election.
It is a revamp of the Scheme proposed before the election, and sunk by Winston Peters, and it is as controversial now as it was then.
The Carrot and stick Approach
The Carrot and Stick Approach to reducing transport emissions provides a rebate of up to $8625 for people buying new EVs with a price cap of $80,000, which starts on July 1, 2021, and a fee imposed on petrol-powered new vehicles of up to $5175. Used cars being registered in New Zealand for the first time will be socked with a fee of up to $2875.
The fees part of the Scheme will kick in from the beginning of next year.
The fees are expected to cover the cost of the rebates, so the government would not have to come up with money of its own.
It is not one-size-fits-all because fees and rebates (hence feebate) vary depending on emission ratings. All the details are reported on RNZ’s website and Checkpoint went shopping at one of Auckland’s largest second-hand low emissions dealers to check out prices.
Electrical Vehicles
Auckland City Electric Vehicles Director Hadley Hargadon had some interesting points to make about what people got for their money.
“Don’t go and buy a $9000 car then expect it to it to do 300 kms on a charge because that is simply not going to be the case,” was one of them.
The price of new and late model EVs and the fact that there are not any on the market so far that fit the bill for tradies and farmers who need big strong Utes are causing the fuss.
On the government’s own figures, New Zealand’s top-selling vehicle, the Ford Ranger, will incur a fee of $2780.
Ms Ardern said that exemptions had been considered but were ruled out because it would be difficult to make them workable.
Motor Trade Association Advocacy and Strategy Manager Greig Epps told Stuff that new electric vehicles started about $48,000 and averaged around $68,000, whereas a really good petrol-powered car could be bought for under $30,000.
He described the Scheme as a step in the right direction but said that the rebates were far smaller than those offered in other countries. He thought that the government might have to reach deeper into its pockets to make a real difference.
Collins tweeted saying that National will fight Labour’s car tax every step of the way.
Her Transport Spokesperson Michael Woodhouse told RNZ that the Policy was “reverse Robin Hood,” taking from the poor to give to the rich.
His Party supported incentives for buying EVs but not the “financial punishment” of those who couldn’t afford them.
‘Punishment’ says Collins
Collins then told Morning Report that the ‘Punishment’ extended to tradies, farmers and others who drove heavy vehicles, and there were not electric-powered alternatives.
They were the ones who were going to have to pay for the government’s failure to deal with emissions, she said.
“I think that the government’s move is simply a tax on those people who have to work for a living to enable others who want to have a ‘nice to have’,” she said.
Her Party would encourage electric vehicles by allowing drivers to use bus lanes and have some free parking and continue exempting EV drivers from road user charges.
It would remove fringe benefit tax for EVs, which would encourage businesses to buy them for their fleets, and that would help create a second-hand market.
‘New Tax’ says Seymour
ACT leader David Seymour joined National in opposing the Scheme, also calling it a tax and accusing Labour of breaking a promise by introducing it.
“Let us be clear. This is a new tax. A tradie or a farmer purchasing a Toyota Hilux will be slapped with a new tax of $2900 and a family buying a Kia Sportage $1230,” he said.
So far there had not been strong opposition to the Scheme from outside the political arena, and Stuff said in an editorial the nation’s transition to electric vehicles had been in second gear, if that, for far too long.
“The greater sense of urgency now being shown by the government is warranted, given the sorry inertia of so many years spent in the transformational slow lane,” it said.
The Scheme was announced by Transport Minister Michael Wood and Climate Change Minister James Shaw, and they emphasised the positive.
Wood said that the discounts would help New Zealand catch up with the rest of the world – monthly registrations of EVs was about half the global average.
Because the fee applied only to the import market, the existing second-hand market that lower-income families tended to buy from would not be affected.
Fleet refurbishment
Wood had previously said that New Zealand’s national fleet is one of the oldest and dirtiest of the developed countries, and something has to be done about it.
Charging an EV at home off-peak was like buying petrol at around 40c a litre and there was less maintenance, he said.
Shaw said that the Scheme was “one of the fundamental shifts” needed in coming years.
And he came up with a new line on Climate Change: “The last time there was carbon dioxide in the atmosphere in the concentrations present today, there were palm trees in Antarctica.”
Apology for Dawn Raids
Ardern made the other big political announcement of the week. She said that Saturday, June 26, 2021, she would issue the government’s formal apology for the Dawn Raids of the 1970s.
The infamous raids began in 1974 when the Labour government clamped down on overstayers. Samoans and Tongans, who had been brought in during the 1950s to relieve labour shortages, were targeted. They were renewed in 1975 under a National government.
The announcement generated a string of emotive accounts and Pacific Peoples Minister William Sio, who was with Ardern at the announcement, had one of his own from when he was a boy in Auckland.
“To have someone knocking at the door in the early hours of the morning with a flashlight on your face, disrespecting the owner of the house, with an Alsatian dog frothing at the mouth at your door, wanting to come in without any respect for the people living in there is quite traumatising… and that was just my family,” he said.
“I do not want my children or any of my nieces and nephews to be shackled by the pain and to be angry about it. I need them to move forward and look to the future, as people of Aotearoa.”
No amnesty, no discrimination
Ardern told a media conference that compensation had not been discussed and indicated another amnesty for overstayers was not on the cards. She said that any amnesty would have to be for all ethnic groups because the government could not discriminate.
The New Zealand Herald quoted University of Auckland Associate Professor of Pacific Studies Dr Melani Anae as saying that the raids were “state-sanctioned terrorism” and the accounts of them were still causing intergenerational trauma and harm.
Ardern said that people had been dehumanised and terrorised in their own homes.
“People were told at that time, “if you did not look like a New Zealander, they carry an ID to prove that you are not an overstayer – you can imagine what impact that has on a community to live in an environment like that.”
She said when computerised immigration records were introduced in 1977 they showed that 40% of overstayers were British and American – groups that were never targeted.
After all the condemnation it was surprising to read a Stuff article that reported overstayers were still being subjected to early morning raids. It said that INZ had confirmed that between May 2020-2021, a total of 223 raids were conducted at private addresses and 19 were between the hours of 6 am and 7 am.
The department was not immediately able to provide a breakdown of those raids by ethnicity.
INZ General manager (Verification and Compliance) Geoff Scott said that standard compliance operations at private addresses were usually carried out between 7 am and 9 pm.
Visits outside those hours were approved on a case-by-case basis because of the likelihood of people of interest being away during standard hours. The last count conducted in 2017 estimated overstayers at approximately 14,000 people, he said.
Pacific nationals (Samoa, Tonga, Fiji, Tuvalu and Kiribati) accounted for a third of the total.
The apology will be delivered by Ardern in Auckland Town Hall.
Vaccination Rollout
Ardern announced details of the vaccine rollout for the general population, those under 65. It will be done in age cohorts, starting with 60 and over from July 28. On august 11, those aged 55 and over will be invited to book for a vaccination.
“When it is your time, you will receive an invite by phone, email. You will be able to choose a location that suits you and you will be asked to book vaccine dates within three weeks of one another,” she said.
An Asia New Zealand Foundation Survey, published by Stuff, showed that China is increasingly being seen as a threat by New Zealanders.
The Annual Survey showed that 35% of people perceived China as a threat, up from 22% last year. Only North Korea and Russia were seen as bigger threats.
“For the first time, more New Zealanders see China as a threat than those who view it as a friend,” the Foundation said.
Peter Wilson is a Life Member of the Press Gallery in Parliament, 22 years as NZPA Political Editor and seven years as Parliamentary Bureau Chief for NZ Newswire. The above article has been published under a special agreement with www.rnz.co.nz; Sponsored by
