The Pavilion overcomes hostility and rivalry
Ali Abbas Ahmadi
London, December 31, 2023
India and Pakistan have long shared hostile relations which often impact cultural exchanges between the neighbouring countries.
But a Pakistani Cricket show aired during the 2023 World Cup managed to overcome these differences.
This was evident at the end of every match in the World Cup (held in October and November) when thousands of Indians flocked to YouTube to watch The Pavilion.
The show, launched in 2021, usually runs only during major Cricket tournaments and features a stellar line-up of former Pakistani players. Its World Cup edition, which ended a day after the final between India and Australia, featured celebrated Cricketers Wasim Akram, Moin Khan, Shoaib Malik and Misbah Ul Haq.
Watching the show, with its well-articulated analysis interspersed with compelling anecdotes and good-natured ribbing, almost felt like spending time with a group of friends talking about Cricket around a table.
Conversational and Light-Hearted
And that is what The Pavilion was always meant to be, says Salman Iqbal, the owner of ARY Media Group, the production company which runs the show.
“We focused on keeping it conversational and light-hearted and rely on experts to give their Cricketing opinion but try not to overcomplicate anything.
“You would not see negativity and toxicity in the show,” Mr Iqbal adds.
But the show’s huge popularity in India still took him and others by surprise.
Several Indian Cricketers, including former Captains Kapil Dev and Sourav Ganguly, have appreciated its format. Indian journalist Rajdeep Sardesai, a fan of the sport, called it “arguably the best Cricket show on the World Cup” because it had “no jingoism, no noise, just solid analysis and truth-telling by former players.”
Many have compared The Pavilion’s success with that of Coke Studio, a long-running Pakistani music programme that also has thousands of Indian admirers.
Akram, a legendary Pakistani fast bowler, told the BBC that The Pavilion was enjoyable for everyone because it was “just an honest show.”
“We just played ourselves. A bit of fun, banter, jokes, stories and, of course, most importantly the Cricket,” he said.
Intense Cricket rivalry
India and Pakistan share an intense Cricket rivalry, and both countries have been known to come to a standstill when their teams lock horns on the field.
But political tensions have meant that Cricket often takes a back seat. The two teams have not toured each other or played a bilateral series in several years.
This year, it was initially unclear if the Pakistani team would even come to India for the World Cup (they eventually did).
Abhishek Mukherjee, Head of Content at the reputed Cricket media house Wisden India, says that it is difficult to explain India-Pakistan tensions to outsiders but adds that the love for The Pavilion is a testament to people in both countries who maintain a deep fondness for each other’s culture.
During the World Cup, clips from the show were widely shared on social media in India, especially the ones where the panellists praised Rohit Sharma’s team.
One of the most popular episodes had Akram defending Indian bowlers after some in Pakistan accused them of cheating at the World Cup. “I want to have the same thing these guys are having,” Akram said about the critics, adding that he would request them not to “open us to ridicule from the world.”
Mr Mukherjee says that the show did not attempt to malign any country, which was refreshing to watch.
“When they talked about Indian Cricket, there was never any effort to bring down India. They were just discussing another team that was playing well.”
Besides, the analysis on the show was “top-notch,” he adds.
Other factors also helped the show become popular in India despite not being broadcast on a TV channel in the country.
The panellists spoke in English, Urdu and Punjabi, languages that many Indians also understand. The former players who appeared on The Pavilion were popular in India and their presence evoked a sense of nostalgia.
“I grew up in the 2000s. The players in the show Misbah Ul Haq, Wasim Akram and Moin Khan, were people I grew up fearing and respecting as an Indian fan,” says Amrit Patnaik, who lives in India’s Orissa state.
“It was really nice to see the same players say such amazing things about India.”
Mr Mukherjee says that the show also filled a vacuum as there was no other comparable Cricket show on Indian TV during the World Cup, despite the country hosting the Tournament. Coverage on Star Sports, the official broadcaster of the tournament, was very India-centric, he said.
The Pavilion is only the latest in a long line of cultural and sporting products that have been celebrated on both sides of the border.
The influence of Bollywood
Pakistanis have grown up on Bollywood films, while soap operas from that country are widely watched in India. Though both governments have restricted cultural exports in recent years, artists from the countries have often collaborated on various projects.
The appreciation extends to Cricket as well. Akram and his teammate Shoaib Akhtar have appeared on Indian talk shows, while another Pakistani Cricketer, Shahid Afridi, once said he got more love in India than at home.
It might be a cliché to say that sport can unite people. But in India and Pakistan, that still rings true, says Mr Iqbal.
“And for a Pakistani Cricketing show to get this kind of appreciation in India is a great indicator of how Cricket holds this immeasurable power to bring people together.”
Ali Abbas Ahmadi is a Digital Journalist at BBC News based in London. The above Report and pictures, which appeared on the publication’s website, have been reproduced here under a Special Agreement.
