Peter Dunne
Jacinda Ardern has my warmest congratulations, my best wishes, and my immense commiserations as she takes on the role of Leader of the Opposition, which she herself has described as “the worst job in politics.”
She is right – it probably is just ahead of being Leader of the Labour Party today.
Unfortunately for Jacinda, this week she inherited both.
Beyond recovery?
She has done so at a time when Labour is probably at its lowest ebb since 1931, and unlike then, when the tide would rise, this time the ebb may be beyond recovery.
Over the last 100 years or so there has been a natural life cycle for major parties of around 60 to 80 years.
Labour today is just over 100 years old – our oldest and longest surviving party.
Curiously, minor parties, possibly because of their definition, do not seem caught as rigidly. Their life cycles are far more erratic, perhaps because they are often more likely to be based around a dominant individual, and their destiny consequently linked to that person’s career, even if the philosophies they represent often emerge elsewhere subsequently.
But, for major parties, the pattern seems far more pre-destined.
Only a dullard, or a “my party, right or wrong” fanatic would deny that reality.
In the early 1900s, the Liberals post-Seddon, and then in the 1920s, conservative Reform post-Massey went through this process, culminating in the rise of the Labour Party from 1916 and the advent of the National Party in 1936.
Alternatives rise
Now, since the 1990s, the rise of left-wing alternatives to Labour – first, the Alliance, and now the Greens – are snapping at Labour’s heels.
The inevitable outcome, maybe sooner rather than later, is that Labour and the Greens will stop cannibalising each other’s votes and refashion themselves into a modern social democratic party on the left of politics. It may well be that in bringing this together Jacinda Ardern will make her greatest contribution.
Shrinking worker class
Labour’s traditional working-class base has been shrinking since the advent of containerisation in the 1970s, and the social conservatism of many of those remaining voters today probably sit more comfortably with the populism of New Zealand First anyway. Certainly, the book of the moment, JD Vance’s Hillbilly Elegy, which offers a credible explanation of the rise of Trumpism in the United States and the rejection there by working class voters in the Rust Belt of traditional left-wing politics in last year’s Presidential election, supports that thesis.
The chasm now emerging between the diminishing traditional working class that Labour has relied on, and the middle-class progressives who over the past 50 years have moved from Holyoake’s property-owning democracy, through Labour’s social liberalism on issues like racism and nuclear weapons, to now reside comfortably with the Greens, has left Labour increasingly bereft.
Now, the Greens are the coming force of the left of politics, and it is not difficult to imagine a Jacinda Ardern/James Shaw team emerging to lead a new single party in the future.
At that point, Labour’s current trauma will end, and the new grouping will at last be able to present itself as the modern viable, left-wing alternative.
Post-National Mix
While National might be safe in the meantime, by virtue of being the very dominant major party in government, it cannot be complacent.
Its day will come too, and it will face the same realignment issues that its old nemesis Labour does today.
But, in National’s case, it is a little more difficult to see immediately how the realignment might occur. The erratic populism of New Zealand First means that, should it survive, it will probably not be part of this process, although its remnants will most likely remain the Social Credit equivalent that has been a near constant feature of our politics over the last 60 years.
By themselves, ACT, UnitedFuture and the Maori Party are probably currently too small, but taken together their particular niches – libertarian laissez-faire; liberalism and aspirational Maori nationalism – could all be valuable additions to the post-National mix whenever it occurs.
And then, as these new parties form, so too will their respective challengers, setting off the process all over again.
As (former Labour Leader) Andrew Little found out this week, in New Zealand politics nothing is forever.
Peter Dunne is Leader of UnitedFuture Party and Interior Minister of New Zealand.
