Alvin Powell
Harvard Business School, USA
May 8, 2020
Brian Strickland was high up in the Himalayas, walking around a rustic clinic a day’s hike from Mount Everest. He was trying to find a cellphone signal strong enough to get email and news from home as the Coronavirus outbreak was evolving from being viewed as a crisis largely focused in central China to a global pandemic centred on the US.
Strickland would be on a helicopter to Kathmandu within days, the first leg of his trip back to Massachusetts, where he would witness the rapid escalation of the Covid-19 epidemic from the intimate point of view of an emergency room physician.
Exploring a therapy
Within weeks, he would be heading a Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) clinical trial exploring the use of inhaled nitric oxide, a therapy built on knowledge gained high in Himalayas, to rapidly kill Coronavirus in the lungs.
“Yesterday was my first full day off in a stretch of 10 days of shifts since I got back,” Strickland said in early April. “It shows how quickly pandemics can completely change our lives.”
The turnaround was breath-taking for Strickland, who is in the first year of a two-year fellowship in wilderness medicine. The unique programme, one of the nation’s oldest, is headquartered at MGH and has a dual focus that seems made for the current crisis: training physicians to deliver medical care in extreme and low-resource settings, and fostering research around problems of low oxygen at high altitude.
Founder N. Stuart Harris, a Harvard Medical School associate Professor of Emergency Medicine and chief of MGH’s Division of Wilderness Medicine, has long studied the effects of altitude sickness and how to treat it in Everest climbers, whose final sprint to the 29,000-foot summit occurs in what climbers call the “death zone,” where air pressure and oxygen levels are too low for normal lung function.
Killing the Coronavirus
That work, Harris said, has led to the current clinical trial, leveraging insights from research done at high altitude to design a treatment that, should it work, would kill Coronavirus directly in the lungs and allow patients to be discharged from the emergency department to home.
The key insight, he said, is that the lack of oxygen at high altitude mirrors the effects of Covid-19’s lung dysfunction on the cell’s mitochondria powerhouse. It is also well-known that nitric oxide, which improves blood flow in the lungs, is central to adapting to life at high altitudes and has antiviral benefits.
“If successful, this relatively simple therapy will give us the ability to treat and safely discharge patients from the ED to home, thereby reducing demand for the extremely limited supply of ICU beds,” Harris wrote in a recent letter to the Division’s supporters.
“This exciting work plays to our strengths of working in concert with the best minds on the planet to seek elegant and innovative low-tech solutions for complex problems.”
What makes a wilderness fellow?
Not every wilderness medicine fellow focuses on the hazards of the Earth’s high places.
Some devote their attention to the challenge of hyperbaric medicine, which treats scuba diving injuries, others to climate change, or life above the Arctic Circle.
Harris said what is common among them, other than a love of the outdoors, is that they see human health as an ecological phenomenon that depends on a functioning biosphere and believe that expert medical care should be available wherever it is required.
“Health care is not an architectural phenomenon. It is about people. Wilderness medicine teaches doctors to provide compassionate, resource-limited medical care under austere conditions. A hospital is a box. We think outside the box,” he said.
Harris said that by stripping away some of the things that have come to be viewed as essential in modern medicine — computers, diagnostic tests, an array of specialists who drop in for brief consultations and then are gone — fellows learn to lean on the relationship between doctor and patient.
Narratively driven
“We are a narratively driven species. In the back country, and the front country, the single most effective diagnostic tool we have is … the stories that we are told and that we tell ourselves. We go outside to become better doctors inside,” Harris said.
Though fellows can customise their experience, many, like Strickland, elect to spend a three-month climbing season at a clinic run by the Himalayan Rescue Association in the village of Pheriche, Nepal. Overlooked by some of the world’s highest peaks, Pheriche, at 14,000 feet, is on one of the main trekking routes to the climbers’ base camp at Mount Everest.
That means the clinic treats many foreign trekkers and climbers, not a few of whom are suffering from the altitude sickness that can result from climbing too quickly for their bodies to adjust.
A starkly different place
When Strickland left for Nepal on February 26, 2020, Coronavirus was a concern, but the vast majority of cases — 78,000 — were still inside China.
Fewer than 3000 cases had occurred outside the Asian giant, and many of those were in South Korea. The US at the time had just 53, all but two of which had origins outside the US.
Strickland spent a week in Nepal’s capital, Kathmandu, getting oriented and taking Nepali language lessons focused on medical terms. At the end of the first week in March, he flew to Lukla, a small town with the airport nearest to his destination.
After that came a four-day hike to Pheriche and the clinic at which Strickland was scheduled to provide care for the next several weeks. As he hiked, Strickland noticed that foot traffic from trekkers and climbers was far below that of a normal season.
“I could see, even in this isolated part of the world, even in the first week of March, the crisis was affecting them,” he said.
When he arrived at the clinic on March 12, 2020, Strickland realised that there would be far less demand for his skills than expected, and his research plans might be in jeopardy.
The next day, the Nepali government confirmed that, halting all mountaineering expeditions and closing the country to tourists.
Though just over two weeks had passed since he left Boston, the world had become a starkly different place. Coronavirus cases in Italy and Iran were soaring and those elsewhere in Europe were expanding rapidly.
US cases, meanwhile, had already topped 1000 and predictions for the coming weeks were dire.
Strickland realised that, while the Pheriche clinic would be unusually quiet, if the pandemic struck Boston in earnest, that would be the place — despite its biomedical sophistication — that would be short of resources and where physicians and other health care workers would be struggling to keep up with the flood of patients.
After talking the situation over with Harris, he made the decision to return.
“We do the training to go where health care providers are needed. There was a need that developed. I saw the situation deteriorating in the US,” Strickland said. “I did the fellowship to do medicine in austere and resource-limited settings, and I realized that’s what’s happening back home.”
Homecoming
Strickland was back in Boston by March 20, 2020.
The change in the ER since he had left was apparent.
Patients were younger. There were more otherwise-healthy 40- to 50-year-olds — a minority of ER patients in normal times — complaining of symptoms of Covid-19.
Intubations, in which a tube is inserted to help a patient breathe, became more common.
“To have a day with 12 intubations for any reason is unusual,” Strickland said. “To have 12 intubations from a single cause is crazy.”
Rare intubations
Far from Boston, 33 miles above the Arctic Circle in the town of Kotzebue, Alaska, intubations are still a rarity. That is where Ashley Weisman, the other fellow in the Wilderness Medicine Fellowship programme, had been providing care at one of the most remote critical-access hospitals in the US.
That facility, run by the regional Maniilaq Association, provides health care services to 8000 people in 12 Native Alaskan villages across the northwest part of the state, a remote region the size of Indiana.
Weisman, who, like other fellows, alternates trips to a remote location with shifts at MGH’s ER, was supposed to be returning to Kotzebue in mid-April.
Quarantine requirements, however, would have put her out of commission for two weeks on either end of the flight. So, she and officials at Maniilaq decided she might be more effective during the crisis if she continued to work at MGH while providing Covid-19 preparatory advice and other help remotely.
Medical resources are much scarcer in Northwest Alaska than in Boston, Weisman said, but in a crisis like this, the region’s two ventilators for 8000 people are comparable to the numbers in Massachusetts. So, like Strickland, Weisman picked up additional shifts in the MGH ER, where in mid-April she estimated that roughly 75% of cases were Covid-related. From the standpoint of “cognitive bandwidth,” however, she said closer to 90% is focused on the condition.
Alvin Powell is Harvard Staff Writer at the Harvard Gazette. The above article appeared in Harvard Gazette of the Harvard Business School, USA.
Photos courtesy of Brian Strickland
