Lydia Lewis
Auckland, November 19, 2024
Fiji’s Prime Minister Sitiveni Rabuka says that as far as Fiji is concerned, Fijians of Indian descent are Fijians.
While Fiji is part of the Pacific, Indo-Fijians are not classified as Pacific peoples in New Zealand; instead, they are listed under Indian and Asian on the Stats NZ website.
“The ‘Fijian Indian’ ethnic group is currently classified under ‘Asian,’ in the subcategory ‘Indian,’ along with other diasporic Indian ethnic groups,” Stats NZ told RNZ Pacific.
“This has been the case since 2005 and is in line with an ethnographic profile that includes people with a common language, customs, and traditions.
“Stats NZ is aware of concerns some have about this classification, and it is an ongoing point of discussion with stakeholders.”
Community Opposition
The Fijian Indian community in Aotearoa has long opposed this and raised the issue again at a community event Mr Rabuka attended in Auckland’s Māngere ahead of the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) in Samoa last month.
“As far as Fiji is concerned, (Indo-Fijians) are Fijians,” he said.
When asked what his message to New Zealand on the issue would be, he said: “I cannot, that is a matter of sovereignty, the sovereign decision by the government of New Zealand. What they call people is their sovereign right. As far as we are concerned, we hope that they will be treated as Fijians.”
More than 60,000 people were transferred from all parts of British India to work in Fiji between 1879 and 1916 as indentured labourers.
Today, they make up over 32% of the total population, according to the Fiji Bureau of Statistics’ 2017 Population Census.
Now many, like Sangam community NZ leader and former Nadi Mayor Salesh Mudaliar, say they are more Fijian than Indian.
“If you do a DNA or do a blood test, we are more of Fijian than anything else. We are not Indian,” Mr Mudaliar said.
The indentured labourers came to be known as the Girmityas, as they were bound by a Girmit, a Hindi pronunciation of the English word “agreement.”
RNZ Pacific had approached the Viti Council e Aotearoa for their views on the issue. However, they refused to comment, saying that its chair “has opted out of this interview.”
“Topic itself is misleading bordering on disinformation and misinformation from an Indigenous Fijian perspective and overly sensitive plus short notice.”
Struggling for identity
“We are Pacific Islanders. If you come from Tonga or Samoa, you are a Pacific Islander,” Mr Mudaliar said.
“When (Indo-Fijians) come from Fiji, we are not. We are not a migrant to Fiji. We have been there for (over 140) years.”
“The community is still struggling for its identity here in New Zealand…we are still not (looked after).
He said they have tried to lobby the New Zealand government for their status but without success.
“Now it is the National government, and no one seems to be listening to us in understanding the situation.
“If we can have an open discussion on this, coming to the same table, and knowing what our problem is, then it would be really appreciated.”
Lifting quality of data
Stats NZ said it is aware of the need to lift the quality of ethnicity data across the government data system.
“Public consultation in 2019 determined a need for an in-depth review of the Ethnicity Standard,” the data agency said.
In 2021, Stats NZ undertook a large scoping exercise with government agencies, researchers, iwi Māori, and community groups to help establish the scope of the review.
Stats NZ subsequently set up an expert working group to progress the review.
“This review is still underway, and Stats NZ will be conducting further consultation, so we will have more to say in due course,” it said.
“Classifying ethnicity and ethnic identity is extremely complex, and it is important Stats NZ takes the time to consult extensively and ensure we get this right,” the agency added.
This week, Fijians celebrate the Hindu festival of lights, Diwali. The nation observes a public holiday to mark the day, and Fijians of all backgrounds get involved.
Prime Minister Rabuka’s message is for all Fijians to be kind to each other.
“Act in accordance with the spirit of Diwali and show kindness to those who are going through difficulties,” he told local reporters outside parliament on Thursday.
“It is a good time for us to abstain from using bad language against each other on social media.”
Lydia Lewis is a Pacific Presenter/Bulletin Editor at Radio New Zealand. The above Report and pictures have been published under a special agreement with www.rnz.co.nz.
