Posted By

Tags

Philosopher encourages dialogue between traditions to reconcile differences

Retired Professor Jaysankar Lal Shaw (RNZ Photo by Kadambari Raghukumar)

Kadambari Raghukumar and Gaurav Sharma
Auckland, January 17, 2025

As a discipline, philosophy has always dealt with existential questions of life, society and the sciences.

Interestingly, modern philosophical thought has come to be dominated by Western thinkers, with ancient Asian schools of the discipline, including Indian and Chinese, taking a back seat.

This has been attributed to the past few centuries of colonialism through which European powers have dominated most aspects of human life.

With the revival of Asia over the past three decades, several scholars of Asian origin have tried to argue the importance of studying comparative philosophy.

About Professor Jay Shaw

Born in the Indian state of Bengal in the 1940s, Shaw had also taught at the University of Hawaii, Alabama University and Jadavpur University in Kolkata, India, before moving to New Zealand in the 1970s.

Retired Victoria University of Wellington professor Jaysankar Lal Shaw is one such scholar. He taught at Victoria University for over four decades, leading courses on Western Philosophy, Māori Philosophy, Confucianism, Buddhism and Comparative Philosophy.

One of Shaw’s key contributions over this time has been putting forward the relevance of Indian philosophy to contemporary Western thinking.

Eighty-four-year-old Professor Shaw has authored more than 14 books on Philosophy and is the recipient of two Festschrifts. A Festschrift is a volume of writings by different authors presented as a tribute to a scholar or an academic.

“Through the course of my career, I have tried to solve some of the problems of contemporary Western philosophy of belief, language, logic, epistemology and ethics from the perspective of classical Indian philosophy. I have found these answers in several systems of Indian Darshan (Hindi word for Philosophy), some in Advaita Vedanta, which is a school of Indian philosophy popularised by Indian saint Swami Vivekananda. Others in the Nyaya, Samkhya and Mimamsa schools of Indian Philosophical thought,” he said.

Fallacies of Bertrand Russell

One example, Professor Shaw said, is how he found a solution to the problem of false beliefs put forward by noted Western philosopher Bertrand Russell in a book titled ‘The Problems of Philosophy.’

“Russell claims that the syllogism in Shakespeare’s Othello is an irresolvable philosophical question. In the story, Othello believes Desdemona loves Cassio. But Desdemona does not love Cassio. So this is an example of false belief. Russell notes none of the Western philosophers have solved the problem of false belief. But we can solve the problem using the Nyaya school of Indian philosophy, which states (that) as Othello is familiar with true love [of the sort he has for Desdemona], he projects that true love between Desdemona and Cassio. So falsehood depends on some truth with which the person is acquainted,” he said.

Exposure to Western and Indian schools of Philosophy has led him to believe in the mutual synergy between the two systems and how they can derive insights from each other.

Maori Philosophy

While at Victoria University, Shaw introduced Māori Philosophy in his courses.

“Māori philosophy is fascinating. It has a different interpretation of the letter i. It refers to the community at large, very unlike the Western individual-centric worldview. Moreover, the concept of oneness that we witness in Indian Advaita Vedanta has several similarities with the Māori worldview,” Professor Shaw said.

The inclusive nature of Indian philosophy, which envelopes all living beings and nature, aligns with how many Māori think, he said and made a distinction between the Indian concept of dharma and the Western concept of religion.

“When we say Dharma in India, it refers to a set of beliefs which are opposed to blind faith or dogma. These beliefs are rational and always compatible with science. Translating dharma as religion doesn’t capture the true meaning of the word,” Professor Shaw said.

Having spent much of his life studying and teaching comparative philosophy, the octogenarian has some words of advice for contemporary philosophers.

“English author Rudyard Kipling famously wrote, ‘East is East and West is West and never the twain shall meet.’ It is not true anymore,” he said.

According to Professor Shaw, we should work towards fostering a dialogue between the diverse traditions of Philosophy, add new dimensions to thoughts and reconcile differences. “This way, we will be able to come up with better solutions to the problems we all face,” he said.

Kadambari Raghukumar is a Producer and Gaurav Sharma is a Senior Journalist at Radio New Zealand, The above Report and picture have been published under a special agreement with www.rnz.co.nz

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share this story

Related Stories

Indian Newslink

Advertisement

Previous slide
Next slide

Advertisement

Previous slide
Next slide

Advertisement

Previous slide
Next slide

Advertisement

Previous slide
Next slide

Advertisement

Previous slide
Next slide

Advertisement

Previous slide
Next slide

Advertisement

Previous slide
Next slide

Advertisement

Previous slide
Next slide

Advertisement

Previous slide
Next slide